| June | 2013 | Ooey Gooey Butter Cake |
| June | 2013 | Cucumber |
| June | 2013 | Strawberry Lemonade |
| May | 2013 | Breakfast of Champions |
| May | 2013 | Chocolate Chip Swirl |
| May | 2013 | Bananas Foster |
| April | 2013 | Grab Bag |
| March | 2013 | Blackberry Merlot |
| March | 2013 | Carrot Cake |
| March | 2013 | Best Boy Balsamic Fudge |
| February | 2013 | Mayan Spice Chocolate |
| February | 2013 | Ambrosia |
| February | 2013 | Love Stinks! |
| November | 2012 | Fourth of July Mix |
| November | 2012 | Scrumdiliumpcious |
| November | 2012 | Dill Pickle |
| October | 2012 | Maple with Bourbon Sugar |
| October | 2012 | Starry Night |
| October | 2012 | Hoppy Halloween |
| September | 2012 | Peppermint Lemonade Twist |
| September | 2012 | Strawberry Hazelnut Swirl |
| September | 2012 | Blueberry with Goat's Milk Cajeta |
| August | 2012 | Sweet Corn |
| August | 2012 | Guinness Stout |
| August | 2012 | White Chocolate Chip |
| July | 2012 | State Fair Elephant Ear |
| July | 2012 | Super Vanilla Bean |
| July | 2012 | Salty Caramel Twist |
| June | 2012 | Lemonade |
| June | 2012 | Crunchy Peanut Butter |
| June | 2012 | Strawberry Basil |
| May | 2012 | Chocolate Surprise |
| May | 2012 | Bourbon Sugar Bourbon |
| May | 2012 | Pineapple & Jalapeno |
| April | 2012 | Sweet Beet Crunch |
| April | 2012 | Cara Cara with White Chocolate |
| April | 2012 | Tax Crunch |
| March | 2012 | Smoke |
| March | 2012 | Dirty Leprechaun |
| March | 2012 | Cinnamon Toast |
| February | 2012 | Super Crunch |
| February | 2012 | Champagne |
| February | 2012 | Black Raspberry Passion Fruit |
| January | 2012 | Caramel Chocolate Chip |
| January | 2012 | Peanut Butter Banana |
| January | 2012 | Year of the Dragon Crunch |
| December | 2011 | Coal |
| December | 2011 | Sticky Toffee Pudding |
| December | 2011 | Pomegranate Kick |
| November | 2011 | Pumpkin Pecan |
| November | 2011 | Bacon Chocolate Chip |
| November | 2011 | Maple and Brown Sugar |
| October | 2011 | Chocolate Hazelnut Swirl |
| October | 2011 | Caramel Apple |
| October | 2011 | Abbey of Gethsemani Pawpaw |
| September | 2011 | Fruit Punch |
| September | 2011 | Dark Chocolate Chip Coconut |
| September | 2011 | Bourbon Sugar Churro with Cajeta |
| August | 2011 | Blackberry Lemonade Twist |
| August | 2011 | Banana Split |
| August | 2011 | Peanut Butter and Jelly |
| July | 2011 | S'more |
| July | 2011 | Banana Pudding |
| July | 2011 | Sweet Corn |
| June | 2011 | Vanilla Lavender |
| June | 2011 | Mango |
| June | 2011 | Hoosier Strawberry |
| May | 2011 | Sun King Brewery Ring of Dingle |
| May | 2011 | Chocolate Caramel |
| May | 2011 | Cherry Limeade |
| April | 2011 | Chocolate Covered Pretzel |
| April | 2011 | Carrot and Gingersnaps |
| April | 2011 | Roasted Coconut |
| March | 2011 | Chocolate Chocolate Chip |
| March | 2011 | Elephant Ear |
| March | 2011 | Praline |
| February | 2011 | Bananas Foster |
| February | 2011 | Key Lime |
| February | 2011 | Raspberry Chocolate Chip |
| January | 2011 | Coffee Chocolate Chip |
| January | 2011 | Pineapple and Mango |
| January | 2011 | Banana Cinnamon |
| December | 2010 | Gingerbread |
| December | 2010 | Candy Cane |
| December | 2010 | Very Vanilla Bean |
| November | 2010 | Cranberry and White Chocolate |
| November | 2010 | Turkey with Sage Dressing |
| November | 2010 | Pumpkin Pie |
| October | 2010 | Cookies and Cream |
| October | 2010 | Saffron and Pistachio |
| October | 2010 | Chocolate Chip Caramel |
| September | 2010 | Pawpaw Almond |
| September | 2010 | Sweet Potato and Ginger |
| September | 2010 | Caramel Apple |
| August | 2010 | Elephant Ear |
| August | 2010 | Cotton Candy |
| August | 2010 | Sour Lemon Shake Up |
| July | 2010 | S'more |
| July | 2010 | Blackberry Vanilla |
| July | 2010 | Caramel Pecan Praline |
| June | 2010 | Cherry Limeade |
| June | 2010 | Chocolate Vanilla Swirl Malted Milk Balls |
| May | 2010 | Banana Pudding |
| May | 2010 | Honey Lavender |
| May | 2010 | Roasted Pineapple |
| April | 2010 | Peanut Butter and Jelly |
| April | 2010 | Chocolate Chip Caramel |
| April | 2010 | Triple Berry |
| March | 2010 | Chocolate Chocolate Chip |
| March | 2010 | Mojito |
| February | 2010 | Pomegranate Rose |
| February | 2010 | Chocolate Swirl |
| February | 2010 | Blood Orange |
| January | 2010 | Dr. Peppery |
| January | 2010 | White Chocolate Snow |
| January | 2010 | Winter Spice |
